Hope Town Council reaffirms ban on backyard chickens within town limits

A view of the gazebo and shelter house at Hope Town Square in Hope, Ind., Monday, Oct. 19, 2020. The town square recently underwent a $437,500 renovation thanks to a partnership with town of Hope and the Indiana Main Street program. Mike Wolanin | The Republic

HOPE Hope has reaffirmed its ban on chickens within the town limits by a 4-1 vote.

The town has a differing viewpoint than Columbus, which went through a lengthy debate on keeping chickens in their backyards in 2016, eventually allowing residents to have as many as four chickens in backyard coops.

But Hope town council members were not dissuaded by the argument that Hope town residents should have the same option as Columbus residents.

Council member Herby Asher made the motion to leave Hope’s current ban on chickens as it is. It was approved 4-1. Only at-large councilwoman Shanon Pittman was in favor of lifting the ban on backyard chickens.

Linda Foote, who lives on Aiken Street in Hope, brought up the point about Columbus, when presenting a petition with 212 signatures requesting chickens be allowed in Hope backyards. Hope’s current population is about 2,100 residents.

In June, Hope Town Marshal Matt Tallent told the council that Foote’s neighbor had made a complaint about the 22 chickens she maintains in her backyard that is on the edge of the town limits. Tallent said Foote was told she had to rehome her chickens within 30 days.

But after Foote outlined what she feels are benefits such as fresher eggs and a means of feeding the poor, the town council gave her a 30-day moratorium on rehoming the birds. Town manager Jason Eckart was asked to research Ordinance 31-2016 in Columbus regarding chickens within the city limits and report his findings back to the council.

On Tuesday, Eckart told the council that if they wanted to adopt an ordinance that mirrors the one in Columbus, he would have town attorney Scott Andrews write an initial draft.

But when council president Ohmer Miller asked for discussion, the council was quiet for a few moments until member John Walstad spoke up.

“I just think we’d be opening up a whole can of worms,” Walstad said. “Next, it’s going to be horses, Then, it’s going to be cows.”

For the complete story, see Friday’s Republic.